Rabbi Moshe ben Maimon—known as Rambam or Maimonides—the 12th-century philosopher, physician, and codifier of Jewish law had a huge and lasting impact on Jewish life. On his gravestone it says, “From Moshe to Moshe, there arose none like Moshe-MiMoshe ad Moshe lo kam k’Moshe. ” This a famous Jewish maxim compares him to Moshe Rabbeinu, the biblical prophet and lawgiver.

I was thinking about this adage on the connection between these two Moshes this week with the advent of this new knesset – parliament, in Israel. This week Yashar MK Matan Kahana was elected speaker in a 66-52 vote, defeating Likud MK Ofir Katz. As he took up the mantle of Knesset Speaker, Kahana promised to work for the good of the entire Israeli public, regardless of “religion, race, or gender” . Kahana took his seat overlooking the plenum to applause from his allies and jeers from his rivals. Otzma Yehudit MK Tally Gotliv and Likud MK Almog Cohen are called to order multiple times during and after the vote, as they repeatedly accuse the Eisenkot-led bloc of relying on “terror supporters” — referring to the Arab led Joint List and Ra’am parties.

In his first remarks, Kahana shared his vision for an alternative to the outgoing government’s approach to its judicial overhaul legislation, saying he hoped the next government “will work to implement necessary reforms to our system of checks and balances — achieved through broad consensus.” He went on to say, “the Knesset will unequivocally abide by the rulings of the court.”
Kahana said that it is the Knesset’s responsibility to move away from the “extremism, hatred, and division” that fill social media algorithms, and to embrace the Jewish school of thought of the House of Hillel, whose followers “made a concerted effort to understand those with whom they disagreed.”
The maxim on Maimonides’ tombstone held the connection between him and Moshe in the Bible. Listening to Kahana’s speech made me realize the stark difference between him and MK Meir Kahane. He was the founder of the Israeli political party Kach, which promoted an ultra-nationalist ideology that continues to influence some militant and far-right political groups active today in Israel.
In a 1984 Knesset speech, Meir Kahane asserted an inherent contradiction between Western democracy and Zionism, advocating for a population transfer of Arab citizens out of Israel to achieve regional peace. The declared “Arabs to Arabia, Jews to Zion.” During his swearing-in to the Knesset in August 1984, Rabbi Meir Kahane interrupted the standard oath of allegiance to recite Psalm 119:44: “So shall I keep the Torah continually forever and ever”
Even if they both have their roots in Bnai Akiva Religious Zionism and share a last name there is a world between Meir and Matan. 42 years later this Kahana concluded the speech with the traditional liturgical line from the Kaddish and Amidah:
“Oseh shalom bimromav, hu ya’aseh shalom aleinu v’al kol Yisrael, v’imru Amen– May God who makes peace in God’s high places make peace upon us and upon all Israel, and say Amen”.
May this be sign of things to come. From Kahane to Kahana may we continue to grow in our religious commitment to the rule of law, democracy, and decency. We still have a ways to go, but we need to take note of the moments of progress. We can only hope that Matan Kahana has a huge and lasting impact on Jewish life. Regardless of religion, race, or gender we should all be blessed with peace.
Leave a Reply